Breaking Dawn: So That Happened
As a man who has been familiar with the plot points of Twilight’s overall story arc but not the particulars thereof, I will say this: I was not prepared. Not for any of it.
And so it begins.
Or should I say ends.
All right, so there’s these three idiots:
- Bella the girl, who’s in love with Edward
- Edward the vampire, who’s in love with Bella
- Jacob the werewolf, who’s in love with Bella and whose facial expression changes not a micrometer throughout the entire movie

Bella’s gentlemen callers Jacob and Edward. Buy the shoes here!
Bella and Edward are finally getting married at the ripe old age of 18 and, what, 110 or something? How old is Edward? How come nobody in his family points out how creepy it is to be a century-plus-old being that wants to get it on with an 18-yr-old?
Actually, there are a lot of questions.
- Does everyone in town know Ed and his family are vampires? If not, how come the wedding is both outdoors and during the day, when the sunlight might hit the Cullen family and make them do that sparkly thing I’ve heard so much about? (btw, at no point in this movie does any vampire sparkle, which now that I think about it means I got robbed, son) Did they have a good cover story ready?
- Speaking of cover stories, how did they account for the fact that everybody on the groom’s side has eyes that are a totally fucked-up color that no natural human has ever sported in the history of our species?
From now on I’m just going to summarize plot points in the shortest possible sentences and save the rest of the room for all the questions I have. Because there are a lot. And I wrote them down, although because it was dark and I was drunk, some of them aren’t as legible as I’d like them to be.
Ed and Bella get married and have their honeymoon on a private island somewhere.
- So the vampires are just filthy rich then? We’re just supposed to accept that they have tons of money and fabulous houses because they’re old? They must have an amazing investment portfolio somewhere.

A traditional American teen wedding.
Ed and Bella finally fuck, but just once, because Ed’s got vampire strength and he bruises Bella up a little, and upon seeing the horror he’s inflicted upon her, he makes a mopey emo vow to himself not to touch her despite the fact that she clearly wants him to.
This is problematic for several reasons.
- First of all, I should note that Robert Pattinson does not seem to be cut out for this swoony teen melodramatic heartthrob role. They made the dude funny-looking. The planes of his face are like the back of a shovel, and the brooding vampire look this material has saddled him with gives him a dead-eyed lizard aspect that made me laugh every time he showed up onscreen for at least the first ten minutes. So there’s that.
- You are now about to witness the strength of nerd knowledge: Larry Niven’s groundbreaking scientific work “Man of Steel, Woman of Kleenex” analyzes the sheer physical challenges presented in the undertaking of sexual relations between a baseline human and a superpowered being. It’s problematic, to say the least. Ed’s got vampire strength, which was demonstrated to us by the movie showing him breaking off part of the bedframe with his bare hands in the throes of passion. This is all just to say that the bruises he put on Bella were not commensurate with his strength. Quite frankly, I’ve known actual real women who’ve demanded worse treatment. Bella got off light, vampire bro, don’t beat yourself up so bad.
- Furthermore, the movie takes great pains to subsequently show us that she still wants it. She wants it bad. Lamb suggested post facto that perhaps this might have been Ed’s biggest problem. “Maybe he just didn’t like that it was consensual.” Does the rest of the franchise imply that vampires are rapists? This thing is just bursting with feminist delight. And the party’s just getting started! (I don’t want to touch Bella’s strong desire for physically punishing vampire sex and its potential for issues around submission and whatnot, because this is Tumblr and I am reviewing a Twilight movie)
Eventually he gets over it and they fuck some more, and then Bella gets pregnant.
And this is where shit goes the fuck off the rails.
The baby’s at least half vampire, right? So it’s super strong and apparently grows really fast? It breaks her ribs. Its demands on her internal systems are such that it’s starving her from the inside out. This is actually pretty horrific to watch — I think that’s where they spent all their CGI money, honestly, because the werewolves are kind of bullshit — and here’s the thing: she really wants to keep it.
Which nobody else in the movie seems to understand. And I’m right there with ‘em. Why? Why do this? Ed doesn’t want her to. Neither does Jacob. But instead of listening to either of the two most important dudes in her life — dudes after whom she wants to name this turbo tapeworm chestburster of a baby if it’s a boy — she decides she really wants to keep it, even if it means she dies in the process. I still do not understand this, and neither does any other character.
For some reason, this makes the werewolves who are hanging out in the woods outside the Cullens’ amazing modernist woodland mansion really angry, and they surround the place — only Jacob and two hangers-on are there to kind of keep the peace. The werewolf peace.
I was under the impression that werewolves were not actually all that scary to vampires. They really shouldn’t be, given the speed and strength I saw the vampires exhibit. But all of a sudden the vampires are worried. They don’t want to leave the house to feed, even.
- Why so worried? Can they not take a werewolf on? They’ve got all this money — why did the Cullens never invest in some shotguns? In case of werewolves? Given that they’re enemies and all? No?
So Bella gets exponentially worse by the day until the vampires figure out the fetus inside her wants blood. Which they put in a styrofoam takeout cup with a lid and a straw for her. There’s already an IV in her, btw, but I guess the filmmakers just wanted that visual. Lo and behold, it makes her feel better, but then she drinks all the spare blood they have, which uh, oops?
Two vampires leave the house to go get some more and there’s an unexciting chase scene. The werewolves really don’t seem all that badass. They’re just oversized wolves. A vampire should be able to take on an oversized wolf, and they do.
Then it’s time for the baby to come out. It kicks so hard it breaks her back. That’s the opener. Then it becomes apparent that they can’t cut it out with conventional tools, and so a thing happens that I had been waiting with gleeful morbid curiosity to witness for a while. Are you ready for this? Here it is:
Ed gets the brainwave to literally bite her uterus open with his vampire teeth to get the baby out. Which he does.
This is a thing that happens in a story loved with a fiery intense passion by millions of teenage girls.
It’s not shown, but it still manages to be surprisingly gross. I remember there being some guts shown, but I might still have been under the influence of the gin. Regardless: it is starkly, shockingly unromantic. It is the opposite of romantic.
Especially because Bella dies half a second later.
At which point Ed gets another brainwave: he goes and gets a syringe full of something he calls his “venom” and pumps her heart full of it.
- I guess in the Twilight universe, vampires inject people with “venom” in order to turn them? Does this mean they have venom glands? Are their fangs injectile?
- Why didn’t Ed just bite her and inject her with his venom? Didn’t he have any in his … venom sacs? I guess I’m just assuming vampires are like rattlesnakes at this point.
The injection doesn’t appear to work, although we’re shown the inside of her body, where it apparently is working, and pretty quickly, too. Silvery liquid shit is flowing all over the place and transforming the crap out of stuff. It should be pointed out that this scene takes place at night.
The werewolves outside the house get the news that Bella’s dead, and they start freaking out and fighting the vampires. Okay.
Meanwhile, inside, Jacob falls in love with a baby.
Let me back up for a second. Apparently, werewolves in this particular fictional universe do a thing called “imprinting” where if they see the love of their life, they just know it from the first glance, and then they’re with that person forever. Forever. It’s a sacred werewolf thing.
Jacob does that with the baby. He sees the baby, and suddenly we’re treated to a weird voiceover montage thing where in his mind’s eye, he sees what the baby’s going to be like when she’s, you know, legal, and that’s supposed to make it okay. Except it’s not. It’s still creepy, because the future baby still looks about 16 and statutory. It’s hilarious. This is easily the funniest part of the movie.

Artistic interpretation of Jacob and the baby he’s straight up gonna bone.
The baby, btw, is named after Ed and Bella’s moms (I think) in a fucked-up concatenation that drew laughs from not only the three of us in the theatre: Renesmee.
So Jacob’s imprinted on the baby, and he goes outside and lets everybody know, and they stop fighting. Apparently anybody on whom a werewolf imprints can’t be harmed. Werewolf honor, y’all. Respec.
Suddenly it’s morning, and the whole house is bummed out about Bella being dead. Presumably hours have passed. How the fuck long does it take to turn a human into a vampire? Those internal shots led me to believe seconds. Minutes at best. Which makes the next part even more ridiculous: suddenly her bones knit, her body fills back out again, color swooshes back into her hair, and her skin acquires both health and makeup, in the span of time it took you to read this sentence. Then her eyes open, and DUN DUN DUN: they’re a ludicrous red.
- How did vampires go undetected amongst civilians before the invention of contact lenses, which I’m assuming the Cullens must have been using to pass amongst the humans of this town?
- Except not, because we see their freaky vampire eyes in the wedding scene? Did they choose this town based on the stolidly uninquisitive nature of its populace? That must be it.
That to me would seem to have been the end of it, but about midway through the credits, we’re shown a scene where these three vampires who apparently spend all their time lounging around in an ancient cathedral basement on uncomfortable-looking thrones are informed about the whole baby thing, whereupon they make vaguely threatening pronouncements.
- These thrones do not look like anything I’d want to sit on for an hour, much less all damn day. Night? There’s no TV, not even a laptop in the room. What the fuck do they do when their messengers aren’t bringing them misspelled news updates?
- PS: these servants are apparently food-grade humans? How’d that girl get tricked into that shitty-ass job?
It’s time for the legendary TASTE rating system to make itself known!
T - Tomfoolery: This movie was pretty hilarious to two separate crowds for two separate reasons. Actual Twilight fans were heard laughing at Twilight injokes that happened mostly during the wedding. That’s fine. Then there were people like us, who laughed whenever Ed was onscreen for the first part, and then at things like the “Renesmee” reveal and Jacob falling in love with the baby. It wasn’t just us! There were others. The birth scene and the baby imprinting scene alone make this a 7, even if it was utterly unintentional.
A - Action: The werewolves do not look good in this movie when there’s fighting. They’re weightless and unconvincing, and I think the exact same .wav was used every time a werewolf took a step in the forest. Vampires with that kind of strength and speed should make for more exciting action, but alas. Alas! 1.
S - Story: Utterly ridiculous. Why would Bella even want to go through all that bullshit with the baby when Ed could’ve turned her into a vampire before getting her pregnant? She didn’t want to, but it’s not explained at all. Her motivations throughout the movie are questionable at best. 3.
T - Titillation: I must have a thing for brunettes, because Bella was lookin’ good for the first 10 minutes of the movie, or however long it took for her to get knocked up. But I admit to being distracted by the presence of Anna Kendrick in the wedding scene, last seen as Stacey Pilgrim in the Scott Pilgrim movie. After Bella gets pregnant, there’s nobody interesting to look at except the vampire girl with the pixie haircut, who has about 40 seconds of screen time, total. And Bella quickly gets extremely grim-looking. Nobody else in the movie is worth mentioning from a physical attractiveness standpoint, which is extra disappointing considering how *~{{sExXxY}}~* our culture has been making vampires for the last decade or so. 3.
E - Everything Else: This thing is utterly ridiculous. It’s worth noting that the musical cues were inappropriate at best, hilarious at worst. I can’t believe there’s a whole ‘nother movie’s worth of story after this. I’m going to need to be even drunker, I think. 2.
- Sung


















